1968-69

Premiers: C Grade (1^st XI).

1969-70

1970-71

1971-72

R/U: B Grade (1^st XI).

1972-73

Premiers: D Grade, F Grade, Under 14.

1973-74

Banyule formed from Rosanna Presbyterians.

1974-75

Premiers: Under 16.

1975-76

Premiers: Under 16.

1976-77

Premiers: B Grade (1^st XI).

1977-78

Premiers: E Grade.

1979-80

Premiers: B Grade (1^st XI), Under 14.

1980-81

1981-82

Premiers: Under 16.

1982-83

R/U: C Grade.

1983-84

Premiers: A Grade.

1984-85

Premiers: A Grade, F Grade.

R/U: Under 16.

1985-86

Premiers: Under 14 (tie).

1986-87

1987-88

Premiers: A Grade, E Grade.

1988-89

Premiers: A Grade.

R/U: B Grade, Under 14.

1989-90

Premiers: A Grade, Under 16.

1990-91

R/U: E Grade.

1991-92

Premiers: Under 16.

1992-93

Premiers: A Grade.

1993-94

Premiers: C Grade.

1994-95

Premiers: A Grade, B Grade.

1995-96

1996-97

R/U: B Grade.

1997-98

Premiers: E Grade (tie).

1998-99

Premiers: Under 12 (tie).

1999-00

Premiers: Under 14.

R/U: A Grade, D Grade.

2000-01

Premiers: A Grade, C Grade, Under 12.

R/U: D Grade.

HDCA Kevin Brady Trophy Winner - Russell Felthouse (A Reserve Grade).

2001-02

Premiers: A Grade, E Grade, Under 14.

R/U: D Grade, Under 12.

2002-03

Premiers: C Grade, Under 16. 

R/U: D Grade, Under 12.

2003-04

Premiers: C Grade, D Grade, Under 12.

R/U: A Grade.